Live survey304 models · 14 providers · 22,792 auditsAudited grill-with-docs · SAFE →What changedHow we verifyllms.txt

Agent skill · Audited from source

Ralph Specum Feedback

skill · tzachbon/smart-ralphMIT licenceAudited 18 Oct 2026 · source a73b124937d9

★ 559pushed 32 days ago
!CAUTIONGrade B · 89/100 · 5 findings · a73b124
559repo stars · whole tzachbon/smart-ralph
InstallView source on GitHub ↗

Is it safe? With care — CAUTION, grade B (89/100). We read this skill's source at commit a73b124937d9 and found no filesystem, network or shell access and no hard-coded secrets. The audit raised 5 findings, 0 critical or high. What it does: This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-feedback`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to draft or submit feedback.

Ask an AI about this pageGChatGPTCClaudePPerplexityGeGeminiXGrok
More
CoCopilotAIGoogle AI Mode
Cite

Cite this page

ModelsAtlas. “Ralph Specum Feedback (tzachbon/smart-ralph)”. Retrieved 18 Oct 2026. https://modelsatlas.com/skills/tzachbon/ralph-specum-feedback

Trust audit

Audit 0.4.1 · source read 18 Oct 2026

Trust score89/100!CAUTION B
0 critical0 high5 medium0 low0 info

CAUTION means the audit found things worth knowing before you trust this skill. Grade B is shared by 16,667 of 17,602 audited skills.

What the source does

  • FilesystemNone observedNo reads or writes in the source
  • NetworkNone observedNo outbound calls in the source
  • ShellNone observedNo commands run in the source
  • DependenciesPinnedNothing floats
  • SecretsNone foundNo keys in source

Five audit layers

LayerWhat we checkResultFindings
L0 ProvenanceRepo owner, licence, archive status, activityWARN5
L1 Static sourceSecrets, path traversal, supply chain, hidden codeNA0
L2 InstructionsPrompt injection, authority framing, hidden directivesPASS0
L3 InventoryThe files and declarations match the sourcePASS0
L4 SandboxRun in isolation and watch behaviourSKIPPED why0

Gates applied: no behavioural pass.

Findings (5)

Audit 0.4.1 · source sha a73b124937d9 · 18 Oct 2026Report an issue or request a re-scan

Provenance

Who published it, and what the verdict is pinned to

  • Publishertzachbon GitHub userOwner of the repository this skill is read from
  • Source foldertzachbon/smart-ralph/plugins/ralph-specum-codex/skills/ralph-specum-feedbackThe exact folder we audited
  • LicenceMITAs the repository states it
  • Commit pinned for this verdicta73b124937d9A new audit runs when the source changes
  • Repository statusNot archivedLast push 32 days ago
  • Sandboxed runNot runSkills are read, not executed; layer L4 is skipped

What it tells the agent

Full source on GitHub ↗

Its description: This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-feedback`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to draft or submit feedback.

---
name: ralph-specum-feedback
description: This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-feedback`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to draft or submit feedback.
metadata:
  surface: helper
  action: feedback
---

# Ralph Specum Feedback

Use this to capture product feedback or bug reports for Ralph Specum.

## Action

1. Summarize the issue, request, or missing behavior.
2. Gather the minimum reproducible context, affected files, commands, environment details, and whether the issue is on the Codex package or Claude plugin surface.
3. If `gh` is available and the user wants submission, create a GitHub issue.
4. If `gh` is unavailable or the user only wants a draft, produce a ready-to-paste issue body and the repository issue URL.

## Output

Keep the report concrete. Include expected behavior, actual behavior, reproduction steps, and any relevant state files or logs.

Excerpt, first 926 characters of SKILL.md, verbatim from the audited commit. It is text from someone else’s repository, quoted so you can judge it before your agent reads it.

Install

Pinned to the audited commit a73b124

Download folder ↗
git clone https://github.com/tzachbon/smart-ralph
git -C smart-ralph checkout a73b124937d9

The author documents no install command, so this uses the repository directly. Our verdict covers commit a73b124937d9 only.

Works in which agents?

What its own text says, not a test

AgentStatusMore
CodexMentioned in its text, not testedSkills for Codex · About Codex
“Mentioned” means the skill’s text names the agent. We have not run it there.

Audit history

Every audit, every source change

  1. !CAUTION B 89 / 100

    first audit · source a73b124937d9

README badge

For maintainers · shows the latest audit

ModelsAtlas: CAUTION BMODELSATLASCAUTION · B 
[![ModelsAtlas: CAUTION B](https://modelsatlas.com/skills/tzachbon/ralph-specum-feedback/badge.svg)](https://modelsatlas.com/skills/tzachbon/ralph-specum-feedback/)

The badge shows our verdict and grade for this skill, and links back to this page. It changes when the audit does.

Similar skills

All coding & review skills →
Ralph Specum!CAUTION

tzachbon/smart-ralph

Use only when the user explicitly invokes `$ralph-specum`, requests Ralph Specum in Codex, or asks Ralph Specum to handle a named phase or optional prototype.

★ 559Grade B
Ralph Specum Cancel!CAUTION

tzachbon/smart-ralph

This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-cancel`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to stop execution or remove a spec.

★ 559Grade B
Ralph Specum Design!CAUTION

tzachbon/smart-ralph

This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-design`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to run the design phase.

★ 559Grade B
Ralph Specum Help!CAUTION

tzachbon/smart-ralph

This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-help`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex for help or command guidance.

★ 559Grade B
Ralph Specum Implement!CAUTION

tzachbon/smart-ralph

This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-implement`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to run implementation for approved tasks, quick mode, or an explicit continue…

★ 559Grade B
Ralph Specum Index!CAUTION

tzachbon/smart-ralph

This skill should be used only when the user explicitly asks to use `$ralph-specum-index`, or explicitly asks Ralph Specum in Codex to generate or refresh index artifacts.

★ 559Grade B

Add this badge to your README

[![ModelsAtlas: CAUTION B](https://modelsatlas.com/skills/tzachbon/ralph-specum-feedback/badge.svg)](https://modelsatlas.com/skills/tzachbon/ralph-specum-feedback/)

Questions about Ralph Specum Feedback

What does the Ralph Specum Feedback skill do?
Spec-driven development with smart compaction. Claude Code plugin combining Ralph Wiggum loop with structured specification workflow.
Is Ralph Specum Feedback safe to install?
With care. The audit graded it B (89/100) and found 5 things worth knowing before you trust this skill, listed below with the exact line each was found on.
What can Ralph Specum Feedback access on my machine?
The audit observed no filesystem, network or shell use at all in its source.
Which assistants does Ralph Specum Feedback work with?
Its documentation mentions codex. That is what the text claims, not a compatibility test we ran.
How current is this page?
The grade is for one exact copy of the source (a73b124937d9), read on 2026-10-18. The repository is watched, and a new audit runs when it changes — this is the first audit.

Sources

Spotted something wrong? Report a correction · Methodology

Keep going in your AI

Opens with this page as the source. We add nothing else to the prompt.